It’s Week Two of our Six Week Challenge to an all natural diet. Last week we discussed artificial colors and flavors, and how they can affect behavior in some very negative ways. Many of you have already begun eliminating foods that contain those ingredients, and I’ve already gotten a few very excited comments about the changes you’re seeing. I can’t tell you how thrilling that is for me! So let’s keep going! For those of you who may be new to this, please read my short article on Circle of Moms that explains how I used an all natural diet to control my daughter’s ADHD like symptoms, here.
This week we will take a look at preservatives. Artificial preservatives are very widely used in modern food products. Most processed food products are made at centralized factories, then shipped across the country to the stores where they’re sold. After delivery they sit on the shelves until they’re purchased. And then, when you get them home they probably sit on your shelf for quite a while too. There are many products that we eat every day that have been chemically preserved so that their expiration dates that several years away. Think for a minute about what that means. If a product won’t break down and begin to decompose after a year in a cardboard box, what do you think it’s doing in your body? Put a conventionally processed cookie on your counter and watch how long it takes for it to rot. I bet you’ll still be watching it years from now. To paraphrase Michael Pollan in his book “In Defense of Food“, if it won’t rot on it’s own, don’t eat it.
The main preservatives that we will focus on for behavior issues are BHT, BHA, and TBHQ, along with nitrates and nitrites.
There are many health reasons to avoid preservatives. Artificially produced preservatives have been linked to lung problems, breathing problems, and asthma. BHT, BHA, and TBHQ have all made the list of known carcinogens in various research studies dating back to as early as 1974 to present. Yet you’ll find them in a large percentage of the processed food you find at your average grocery store. In addition to those serious health issues, studies by numerous researchers have also directly linked BHT, BHA, and TBHQ to hyperactivity in children. And it seems the more they are the exposed the worse the problems become, building up over time. In my own experience I’ve noticed that it takes Sophie longer to recover after eating these preservatives than any other artificial ingredients. This stuff just seems to hang around in her system longer than anything else.
You’re most likely to find BHT, BHA, and TBHQ in products that come in boxes and bags. Cereal, crackers, cookies, macaroni and cheese, and even some dairy products. Some nut manufacturers use it as well, so always pay attention to those labels. Look for it in the frozen section too in frozen pancakes and baked items. If you see capital letters in the list of ingredients, put it back. Easy, right? I find most of my preservative-free items in the organic section, but there are still a few rule-breakers out there, so don’t assume anything.
The other group of preservatives to avoid for better health and behavior are nitrates and nitrites. These are notoriously found in cured meats such as hot dogs, bacon, lunch meats, and sausages. They have both been linked in research studies to asthma and breathing problems, as well as being included on the list of known carcinogens. These ingredients can also cause behavior problems in children. But I want to be clear in noting that there are different versions of nitrates and nitrites. Most conventional cured meats contain a synthetic version of these two ingredients, usually noted as “sodium nitrate/nitrite” or “potassium nitrate”. These are artificially created versions that routinely contain arsenic and lead, among other things
. The options you’ll find to replace the products you normally use almost always contain naturally occurring nitrates and nitrites. These are derived mostly from celery, and are considered to be safe by most people. To put it in perspective, almost all leafy green vegetables contain naturally occurring nitrates and nitrites. The difference is that phrase “naturally occurring”. My advice when it comes to eating cured meats is to always purchase the best quality possible, making sure there are no synthetic nitrates/nitrites, and eat them in moderation. My favorite source for everything from hot dogs to bacon to chicken nuggets is Applegate Farms. You can find them at many conventional grocery stores, as well as Target, Whole Foods, and Trader Joes. If you can’t find acceptable nitrate/nitrite free products at your store then talk to the manager and make a request.
I’ve seen first hand the difference removing artificial preservatives has made in my daughter’s ability to follow directions and control her behavior. As I stated before, these chemicals have a tendency to remain in the system longer than the artificial colors and flavors we discussed last week, so it may take a little longer for you to see the results. Just stick with the program and you’ll be glad you did.
If you haven’t already, please read my post from Week One: artificial colors/flavors. There are a few bits of information in there that can benefit everyone who is working towards an all natural diet, especially those of us with chemically sensitive children.
You may also like:












I am so happy to be a part of your six-week challenge. Question: I am confused about the term, "natural flavoring". Is this really natural or is it a gimmick term? Why don't manufacturers list the actual ingredients that provides the flavor?
Thanks!
This is not the most exciting reply I've ever written, but I wanted to pass along the information as I knew it. So here's a direct quote from the government regulations that pertain to what constitutes "natural flavoring". It's a thought provoking conversation to say the least, and something that I struggle with on a regular basis…If you're vegetarian, vegan, have food allergies, or are celiac, you need to beware of "natural flavoring"-
"The term natural flavor or natural flavoring means the essential oil, oleoresin, essence or extractive, protein hydrolysate, distillate, or any product of roasting, heating or enzymolysis, which contains the flavoring constituents derived from a spice, fruit or fruit juice, vegetable or vegetable juice, edible yeast, herb, bark, bud, root, leaf or similar plant material, meat, seafood, poultry, eggs, dairy products, or fermentation products thereof, whose significant function in food is flavoring rather than nutritional."
Oh, I also meant to say I'm glad you're doing the challenge too! Thanks – and I'm glad you asked this question – I'm putting it on the list of posts I need to write.
We started the challenge last week. Getting the food coloring out of our diet was not difficult. Thankfully, I've been working on that awhile. This week will present my biggest challenge. I was amazed as I bought groceries this morning as how many capital letters were in ingredients lists. Those items stayed out of my basket. My boys are excited to help me make your homemade granola today. I promised them chocolate chips (Ghiardelli) on top of their bars.
Thanks for the challenge!
We just had a new ceiling put in our kitchen a couple weeks ago and so all of my "stuff" was moved to the dining room. After seeing my clean non-cluttered kitchen I decided to get rid of a lot of the decor stuff that was filling my surfaces. As I boxed up some thing I opened a large decorative cookie jar to clean inside. There I found an open half full bag of vanilla wafers that looks a little bleached out but otherwise exactly the same as a fresh box. I am figuring that they have been in there at least 6 years because that container was put on top of a piece of furniture when we moved into this house and not used!! Talk about not breaking down – Yikes and I eat that stuff.
Mia, I'm so glad you're doing the challenge, and obviously making great choices! I hope your boys love the granola bars.
Lisa, that is such a great story to prove my point! Thanks for sharing it!
I too am excited about this 6 week All Natural Challenge. I have two questions. My first question, was about "natural flavoring" So thank you for answering. My second question is not about food, but about beverages. Occasionally I will buy Sierra Mist Lemon-Line & delude with water; however, my husband, being from the South, loves sweet-tea. I prefer not having this option for my 8 yr. old son. Any suggestions?
Hi Sabrina,
Sierra Mist is all natural, and it's great you're diluting it. Stay away from the diet version because of artificial sweeteners. In our house we have water, milk, orange juice and lemonade for drink choices. Minute Maid all natural (not the pink lemonade version), Newman's Own, and Simply Lemonade/orange juice are the ones I use. I still cut those in half with water too. Sophie used to be the biggest juice addict around but now she actually asks for water. I'm still amazed by that.
Okay I'm trying to tackle cereal just on it's own for now. The only one I have here that says "no preservatives" is Raisen Bran. I don't get how it can have none. Raisen Bran would last forever I'm sure. I have also bought some with "tocopherols (Natural Vitamin E) for freshness" it says. When I look it up on the interest it labels it as TCP (another set of acronyms). What about this TCP??
My son loves Honey O’s from Trader Joes, but when I read the ingredients and heard how cereal can affect behavior I stopped giving it to him. I found a cereal that I still don’t know if it’s “allowed”, but it has about 7 ingredients (it’s gluten and wheat free) and and I know what they all are. It’s called Nature’s Path -Peanut Butter-Panda Puffs (I’m sure there are other flavors). I told him he is allowed to have it only once a week, though he still begs for the Honey O’s every once in a while.
Here’s the website http://www.naturespath.com.
Good luck with the cereal challenge~
oops I just read when you posted this comment…I’m sure you have rectified this by now.
Oh I forgot about nitrates in meats. I have been trying to eliminate this for a whole but have a hard time with some products. I have Country Naturals and a few others for sliced lunch meats but pepperoni and other such meats I am having a hard time with. How do you make pizza without pepperoni. So if you have any sources of pepperoni either in sticks for eating or for slicing let me know. I am in Canada so if might be hard for me to find them.
Week one wasn’t really that bad, my son rarely ate foods that contained the week one no no’s, as for week two well that will be a bit more of a challenge for me on the shopping side. But with your recommendations for Applegate Farms, and where to find that brand makes it easier. You think one eats healthy, then you read your info about what is in the food you think is good for you, and not so much.
Thanks again for all of your info…I do hope the diet change will help. We have a Dr.s appt. tomorrow, first one, to see what they found out with the Connors test we filled out.
What about Sodium phosphate?
Sodium phosphate is a naturally occurring ingredient. It’s usually added to lunch meats and cheeses to help preserve them. These are generally highly processed foods that need to be monitored very closely. Usually in products like those there is something else besides the sodium phosphate that would cause you to avoid them. If sodium phosphate is the only added ingredient or is part of a short list of other natural ingredients then it’s probably a safe food. Here’s a short article from LiveStrong that explains sodium phosphate well. http://www.livestrong.com/article/8735-need-sodium-phosphates/
Thank you~